דיווח • Board Game Arena

כל הדיווחים

עלים דווח על

#25677: "For a nil bid, the partner's books are not added to team bid."

notabug: זה לא באג

על מה דוח זה?

עלים #115159298

מה קרה? אנא בחר מהרשימה מטה

חוקים:חוק של המשחק לא כובד

מה קרה? אנא בחר מהרשימה מטה

חוקים:חוק של המשחק לא כובד

בבקשה בדוק אם יש כבר דוח על אותו נושא

אם כן, הצביעו בעד הדיווח הזה, דיווחים עם הכי הרבה קולות נחקרים ראשונים

#	Status	Votes	Game	Type	Title	Last update

תיאור מפורט

היסטוריית דיווחים

2020 3 Oct 04:12 • R o d n e y • הבאג עוד לא שוחזר על ידי המפתחים:

imgur.com/a/UAS1gGF

2020 4 Oct 00:10 • VinceS • זה לא באג:

The situatiation you are describing is according to the rules used for this implementation (see rules link to pagat.com)
"The usual rule is that when a nil fails, the tricks won by the nil bidder do not count towards making the partner's bid, but do count as bags for the team."

2020 4 Oct 06:06 • mimne • זה לא באג:

Can we have this be an option?
I get that it's the usual rule, but it does seem to be pretty punitive

2020 10 Oct 22:44 • sfoozy • זה לא באג:

Ya, I'm not a fan of this rule and wish it were optional. I know there may be a handful of variants... but logically, it does not make sense not to count a trick that your partner takes just because they had bid NIL. It's a trick ... why is it treated like it's invisible?

2020 27 Oct 11:18 • JusterGame • זה לא באג:

But if one bids NIL, then the making of any tricks (1) must lead to bags and (2) are not tricks that the player SOUGHT to win, so shouldn't count as though they were.

Further, if they DID, and if the non-zero partner also got MORE than they bid, then logically the zero player's tricks should ALSO count as bags within their partner's score. You can't have your cake AND eat it !

2020 27 Oct 12:37 • VinceS • זה לא באג:

I guess the logic here is, that as soon as one player bids nil, the team is seperated into two individuals for scoring (because you can get nil only as an individul). After calculating the scores for both players without looking at the partner, the scores are summed up for the team.

The tricks of the Partner do not count for the nil-bid and the tricks of the nil-player do not count for his partner.

Example:
Player 1 -> Bid 0 / Got 2 Tricks --> -100 for Nil-bid / 2 Bags (took more tricks than he/she bid)
Player 2 -> Bid 4 Got 5 Tricks --> 40 for Bid / 1 Bag (took more than bid)
Team --> - 60 Points / 3 Bags

This seems logical to me

2020 2 Nov 23:35 • mimne • זה לא באג:

It's totally logical, and the correct rule, and it should be the default for sure. It's just, it's hard enough to get people to play Spades, and this is a common house rule that fits with it being a team game so if it's possible to have it be an option, that'd be nice. :) Clearly this is not a must have, nor is it high priority.

2020 2 Nov 23:38 • mimne • זה לא באג:

Err, to clarify, I don't think this is a bug, which is how it was originally reported. More like a request? Is it better to file a separate report marking it as a request? Or don't bother? :)

2020 3 Nov 14:46 • Jban • זה לא באג:

Just to confirm, the way I have always played the game. The nil bid is the only solitary bid in the game, so as a result the 4 bid of the partner is still a team bid. So both players can add to achieving that.

I don't have any official ruling reference, but just wanted to address that the reasoning (initially reported as a bug) is not uncommon.

2020 10 Dec 22:14 • Supergravity • זה לא באג:

When I was playing money spades, the nil rule was that if you break the partner, you break the nil as well, and if you break the nil, you break the partner as well. In either case the score was just -100, and the bags are the number of tricks by which the partner's bid was exceeded.

הוסף לדוח הזה

הוסף כאן כל מה שנראה שייך כדי לשחזר את הבאג או להבהיר את ההצעה שלך:

מספר שולחן/מהלך אחר
האם לחיצה על F5 פתר את הבעיה?
האם הבעיה הופיע כמה פעמים? בכל פעם? באופן אקראי?
אם יש לך צילום מסך (מומלץ) אתה יכול להשתמש ב Imgur.com כדי להעלות אותו להדביק קישור לכאן.

מבוטל מעדכן נתונים

#25677: "For a nil bid, the partner's books are not added to team bid."

על מה דוח זה?

מה קרה? אנא בחר מהרשימה מטה

מה קרה? אנא בחר מהרשימה מטה

בבקשה בדוק אם יש כבר דוח על אותו נושא

תיאור מפורט

היסטוריית דיווחים

הוסף לדוח הזה

שנה את מצב הדיווח ל:

עזרה

תרום

נווט

עקוב אחרינו